🍟 Saving Great Movies from Rotten Scores 🍅
Because Sometimes Critics Get It Wrong
We're not afraid to say what everyone's thinking. Join us as we expose the most overrated films and defend the underrated gems that deserved better.
Tomato Scores
QUESTIONED
Potato Scores
CORRECTED
Saved from the Critics
Eternal Shadows
A haunting exploration of memory and loss that critics misunderstood.
Critics Say
42%
VS
We say
89%
Saved from the Critics
Focus
Focus follows veteran con artist Nicky and newcomer Jess, whose growing connection complicates a high-stakes scheme where trust is the most dangerous gamble.
Critics Say
55%
VS
We say
80%
Trending This Week:
Action
Jumper
2008
15%
55%
Do you agree with our score?
123
.png)
82
60% agree
.jpg)
Musical
The Phantom of the Opera
2005
32%
82%
Do you agree with our score?
132
51
72% agree
Adventure
Hook
1991
29%
72%
Do you agree with our score?
101
61
62% agree
Action
Sucker Punch
2011
22%
60%
Do you agree with our score?
94
70
57% agree
Action
Book of Eli
2010
46%
77%
Do you agree with our score?
141
60
70% agree
.jpg)
Comedy
Step Brothers
2008
55%
88%
Do you agree with our score?
201
40
83% agree
CRITIC DISAGREEMENTS
Films we disagree with
Discover films where professional critics and real movie lovers see things differently
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
.jpg)
🍟 Critics overlooked, we paid attention
Sci-Fi
In Time
2011
36%
83%
Do you agree with our score?
165
40
80% agree
Horror
Saw
2004
50%
91%
Do you agree with our score?
193
31
86% agree
Fantasy
Twilight
2008
48%
87%
Do you agree with our score?
151
73
67% agree
Martial Art
Kung Pow
2002
13%
65%
Do you agree with our score?
111
90
55% agree
Join the Movement
Have a Rating the Critics Got Wrong?
Submit your movie for review and help us expose more unjust ratings
CRITICS
Their Score
SPUDS
Your Score
We review all submissions and add the best ones to our collection
500+
Movies Reviewed
50K+
Spud Squad Members
1M+
Votes Cast
.png)
Parody Disclaimer:
Rotton Potatos is a parody website created for entertainment purposes. All movie scores, reviews, and ratings are fictional and meant for fun. We have the utmost respect for film critics and their work. This site is not affiliated with or endorsed by Rotten Tomatoes or any movie review platform. Enjoy responsibly! 🎬🍟
LINKS
Home
Submit a Review
DESIGNERS SOCIALS
TikTok
Instagram
Youtube
STAY CONNECTED
Get the latest news & updates
© 2026 Rotten Potatoes
Made by Taylor Zipp